12 Top Pumpernickel Bread Brands You Need to Try

Discover the best pumpernickel bread brand that elevates your meals with rich flavor and texture. Find the perfect loaf for every occasion.
12 Top Pumpernickel Bread Brands You Need to Try

Top Quick Picks For You

Best Low-Cost Alternative

Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread offers a cost-effective option while maintaining quality and taste, making it perfect for budget-conscious consumers.

Best for Health Conscious

Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Bread is high in fiber, made from natural whole grains, and supports a healthy diet, making it an ideal choice for health-conscious individuals.

Best for Sandwich Lovers

Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Stern’s Bakery Pumpernickel Bread is pre-sliced and specifically designed for making delicious sandwiches, ensuring convenience and great taste for sandwich lovers.

Best for On-the-Go Meals

Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Stern’s Bakery Pumpernickel Bread's pre-sliced design makes it easy to use for quick meals, perfect for those who need a convenient option for on-the-go dining.

Best Pumpernickel Bread Brand

Are you ready to embark on a delightful journey through the world of pumpernickel bread? This deep, dark, and richly flavored staple not only adds a unique twist to ordinary meals but also enchants the palate with its nutty undertones and dense texture. Join us as we explore the best pumpernickel bread brands that promise to elevate your culinary creations, from hearty sandwiches to elegant hors d'oeuvres.

Best Low-Cost Alternative: Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread 17.6 oz each (1 Item Per Order)
Highlights
All-natural ingredients
Dense and filling
Great flavor options

When it comes to pumpernickel bread, we find that Mestemacher shines as the Best Low-Cost Alternative without sacrificing quality .

This all-natural, whole grain delight is dense and filling, making it an excellent choice for those who want a satisfying bite .

With a variety of flavor options, there’s something for everyone .

While some may find its texture a bit dry or crumbly at times, the delicious taste and affordability make it a standout .

For budget-conscious consumers, Mestemacher offers a compelling option that won’t break the bank while still delivering on flavor and nutrition.

Be sure to also check out the best ground beef brands for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Pumpernickel on Amazon

Best for Health Conscious: Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Bread, Pumpernickel, 17.6 Oz, Pack of 12
Highlights
High in fiber
Nutritious whole grains
Long shelf life

When it comes to pumpernickel bread, our team is all aboard the Mestemacher train !

This bread is a health-conscious dream, packed with nutritious whole grains and a hefty dose of fiber .

Made fresh at the Mestemacher Mill, it not only keeps you feeling satisfied longer but also supports your digestive health .

Sure, its dense texture may be an acquired taste for some, but we say it’s worth the leap for a slice that’s preservative-free and backed by NASA !

Whether you enjoy it fresh or toasted, Mestemacher Pumpernickel shines as an ethical choice and a tasty, low-carb option perfect for any meal.

Be sure to also check out the best peeled garlic for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Pumpernickel on Amazon

Best for Sandwich Lovers: Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Pumpernickel Bread -2 Pack-16 oz Per Loaf | Delicious Sandwich Bread | Kosher Bread | Fresh Bread | Dairy & Nut Free | Stern’s Bakery
Highlights
Fresh and tasty
Fluffy and flavorful
Kosher and allergen-free

When it comes to finding the best pumpernickel bread for your sandwich needs, we believe Stern’s Bakery has truly outdone themselves .

This pre-sliced delight is perfect for sandwich lovers, giving you that luxurious fluffiness and robust flavor that elevates any meal .

With a commitment to quality, their bread is baked fresh daily, ensuring you enjoy each bite .

Sure, it might be a bit on the pricier side, but the convenience and taste undeniably make it worth it .

Plus, it’s kosher and allergen-free, effectively catering to a wide audience .

Perfect for gatherings, this bread will leave your guests satisfied!

Be sure to also check out the best pancake batter dispenser for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Stern's Pumpernickel Bread on Amazon

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread (Pumpernickel, 17.6 oz, pack of 2)
Highlights
High in fiber
No preservatives
Kosher certified

We’ve found a standout contender in the pumpernickel bread category !

This brand delivers deliciously dense slices packed with high fiber benefits, making it perfect for health-conscious eaters .

We love its no preservatives policy and its Kosher certification, which means you can enjoy it guilt-free .

Just remember, the flavor can be an acquired taste, and popping it in the toaster is a must for that perfect crunch .

While some may face gastrointestinal issues, many agree that the texture and taste are worth it .

So, if you're in the market for pumpernickel, give this one a try — toasted, of course!

Be sure to also check out the best gnocchi board for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread on Amazon

Mestemacher Pumpernickel

Mestemacher Bread Pumpernickel, 17.6 Oz (Pack of 6)
Highlights
Great taste and texture
Freezes well
European quality ingredients

When it comes to pumpernickel bread, we can confidently say that Mestemacher delivers a standout option that's hard to resist .

With a delightful taste and texture, this bread is made from European quality ingredients that elevate every bite .

We appreciate that it freezes well, making it a convenient choice for meal prep or last-minute sandwiches .

However, be prepared—this gem isn’t the easiest to find in stores, and its thin slices may leave some bread enthusiasts wanting more .

Priced at a premium, Mestemacher earns its position as a top contender, especially for those who prioritize quality in their culinary adventures.

Be sure to also check out the best dumpling maker for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Pumpernickel on Amazon

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread Brand

Mestemacher Natural High Fiber Bread 3 Flavor Variety Bundle: (1) Mestemacher Organic Three Grain Bread, (1) Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread, and Mestemacher Whole Rye Bread, 17.6 Oz. Ea. (Pack of 3)
Highlights
Whole grain goodness
High fiber content
Great for toasting

When it comes to finding the best pumpernickel bread, we can't overlook the Mestemacher brand .

This whole grain delight is not just packed with high fiber goodness, but it's also perfect for toasting up a storm .

With a solid 4.1-star rating from over 700 reviews, it’s clear that many appreciate its unique flavor .

However, keep in mind that the packaging can be a tad fragile and the bread has a tendency to crumble if you're not careful .

While it's not the easiest loaf to find, its rich taste and texture make it worth the hunt!

Be sure to also check out the best honey refractometer for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher on Amazon

Pepperidge Farm Bread

Pepperidge Farm Bread, Dark Pumpernickel, 16 Ounce
Highlights
Fresh and timely delivery
Highly recommended by users
Good quality, healthy bread

We had a delightful experience trying the Dark Pumpernickel bread, packaged conveniently in a 2-pack for your culinary adventures .

We appreciate the fresh and timely delivery, which is essential for bread lovers !

Users highly recommend this loaf, and we can see why—it's a quality option that’s also healthy .

However, it’s worth noting that some may find it a bit overpriced given the quantity, and the flavor might not hit all the right notes for everyone .

Overall, if you're looking to give your sandwiches a nutritious twist, this bread is certainly worth considering!

Be sure to also check out the best dumpling press for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Pepperidge Farm Bread on Amazon

S. Rosen's Pumpernickel Rye Bread

S.Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel (Case of 4 Loaves)
Highlights
Great for tiny sandwiches
Perfect for appetizers
Delicious and toasts well

When it comes to finding the best pumpernickel bread, S .

Rosen's mini slices are definitely a standout choice .

These 2.5" square delights are tailor-made for tiny sandwiches and will elevate your appetizer game at any gathering .

With 35 slices per loaf, you can whip up a delightful spread that will impress your guests—five slices make a perfect serving !

Just keep in mind, we’re a bit reliant on their shipping rhythm—orders are only shipped once a week, so plan ahead .

Overall, if you're looking for a delicious option that toasts beautifully, S .

Rosen’s is a tasty contender!

Be sure to also check out the best ice cream cookbook for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for S. Rosen's Pumpernickel Rye Bread on Amazon

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Pumpernickel Bread Brand

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread 17.6 oz each (2 Items Per Order)
Highlights
Tasty texture
Low calories
Versatile toppings

When it comes to finding the best pumpernickel bread, we can’t help but rave about this standout option .

Its tasty texture is perfect for those who love a nuanced flavor without the extra calories .

We appreciate that it pairs beautifully with a variety of toppings, making it a versatile choice for anyone's kitchen .

However, do note that it doesn’t come in your typical loaf form and requires a bit of planning since it needs to be frozen .

Despite its limited use cases, this bread is a delightful addition for any pumpernickel lover looking to elevate their culinary creations!

Be sure to also check out the best turkey brining bag for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Pumpernickel on Amazon

Stern's Pumpernickel Bread

Pumpernickel Bread -2 Pack-16 oz Per Loaf | Delicious Sandwich Bread | Kosher Bread | Fresh Bread | Dairy & Nut Free | Stern’s Bakery
Highlights
Fresh and fluffy texture
Convenient pre-sliced loaves
Kosher certified and allergen-free

When it comes to pumpernickel bread, we’ve found a delightful gem with Stern's Bakery .

Their pre-sliced loaves offer a fresh and fluffy texture that keeps your taste buds dancing .

Whether you're crafting a sandwich or enjoying a simple breakfast, the convenience of pre-slicing makes it a breeze .

You’ll appreciate that it’s kosher certified and free from common allergens, perfect for any gathering .

While the loaf might be smaller and pricier than other options, the quality and flavor make it worth every penny .

Just a heads up—be mindful of storage to avoid any staleness issues .

Trust us, your guests will love this delicious addition!

Be sure to also check out the best commercial food steamer for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Stern's Pumpernickel Bread on Amazon

Mestemacher Rye Bread

Mestemacher Rye Whole Bread, 17.6 Ounce - 1 each.
Highlights
Great taste
Sturdy for sandwiches
Healthy dense rye

When it comes to pumpernickel bread, Mestemacher Bread Whole Rye stands out with its robust flavor and health-packed ingredients .

We love how its dense texture makes it perfect for sandwiches, providing a satisfying bite without falling apart .

However, be prepared for a slightly crumbly texture that could leave a few crumbs behind !

While it leans towards the dry side, it shines when paired with spreads or toppings .

Although availability could be a hurdle for some, the taste and nutritional benefits make this bread a worthy addition to any gourmet kitchen .

Give it a try—you won’t regret it!

Be sure to also check out the best powdered sugar shaker for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Mestemacher Rye Bread on Amazon

PuroRaw Dark Rye Flour Pumpernickel Bread Brand

PuroRaw Dark Rye Flour, 2lbs, Dark Rye Flour for Bread Machine, Pumpernickel Flour, Whole Rye Flour for Baking, Rye Bread Flour, Pumpernickel Meal, Non-GMO, Batch Tested, Product of Canada
Highlights
High nutritional value
Versatile baking ingredient
Suitable for many diets

At the heart of our quest for the best pumpernickel bread brand, we turned to PuroRaw's dark rye flour, a true gem in the world of baking .

This 100% all-natural flour retains the germ and bran, delivering a punch of nutrients and fiber that white flours simply can't match .

Perfect for those looking to whip up hearty pumpernickel or versatile rye breads, it’s also a great addition to cookies, pizzas, and more .

While the packaging could be better, the earthy flavor and health benefits make it a must-have for any kitchen .

Dive in and elevate your baking game!

Be sure to also check out the best quick meal cookbooks for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for PuroRaw Dark Rye Flour on Amazon

🎯 Popular Posts

Never Miss A Post!

Sign up for free to Seasoned Slice and be the first to get notified about updates.

Never Miss A Post! 🎉
Subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest deals and news
  • 01Get discounts on products and memberships
  • 02Get notified about new posts, reviews and updates
subsc